Stay: The New Migration Challenge Germany Can’t Ignore

Ivan Gabor,

Willkommen
Germany urgently needs international talent — yet one in four newcomers is considering leaving again. In his latest reflection, Ivan Gabor argues that the real challenge isn’t only attracting workers, but building a society where they want to stay. He calls for a bold narrative shift: a Germany that integrates itself into an inclusive, collaborative, future-ready reality.

If nothing changes demographically, Germany will have 16 million fewer workers by 2060 than today. According to most projections, the country needs around 400,000 new workers every year from abroad.

We often hear this fact in the news, but what we hear much less about is how many international people leave Germany again—and this seems to be becoming a growing problem. A new study shows that one in four people who come from abroad considers leaving. The reasons vary — family, work, returning home — but every second person in this group thinks about leaving because of the political climate. And it’s not rocket science to guess why: people with a migration background who have no intention of leaving are particularly worried by words like “Remigration” or “Passdeutsch.”

In Germany, over 10 million people were born outside the country. The share of the population varies widely depending on the region. In Berlin or Bremen, it is around 30% (including those who obtained citizenship); in Saxony, about 8%. I spoke with someone from Saxony-Anhalt who told me: “You in Berlin can’t even imagine how strong the hostility towards migrants (‘Migrationsfeindlichkeit’) is in my region.”

So what can be done?

One response from the federal government was the creation of a new agency called Work and Stay, designed to bring people in and help them remain in the country.

A strong example from civil society is Workstadt in Wuppertal. They run a “stay” programme financed by companies. The average recruitment cost of one skilled worker is €27,000, which means a company that needs 100 workers a year spends close to €3 million just to bring people here. So if — statistically — one in four leaves again, this creates a massive loss. That is why companies in Wuppertal contribute a fee to fund Workstadt. Their work has not only social value but a very clear economic one.

In discussions with people across various levels, one thing becomes clear: we need a narrative shift in the field of migration. A new mindset about how we see society and the role of international people within it. To put it very clearly: not only immigrants need “integration” — the whole society needs to integrate, to adapt to a new, inclusive, collaborative reality. A society that runs on technology and AI. The question is how humans can get the most out of technology while remaining human – and how Germany can transform into an international society where everyone proudly keeps their cultural roots.

Inclusivity, digitalisation, humanity, local democracy, solidarity — these are the driving forces behind the most innovative societies in the world, from Taiwan to Finland. The key in such a transformation lies in decentralised networks and in building an innovative system that can feed and strengthen those networks.

We would love to hear your thoughts on this topic.
Write to us at heypost@wahlheymat.de

Author:

More From WahlheYmatPost

  • Who Will Lead Germany Into Its International Future?

    Who Will Lead Germany Into Its International Future?

    What does the story of Charles De Gaulle teach us? Antonin Baudry’s La Bataille de Gaulle tells, in five hours, the story of the General during the Second World War. A great movie. I learned a lot. Tenacity. De Gaulle arrives alone in London. On 18 June 1940, he makes his first BBC speech, speaking…

  • Berlin Wiki: What Are the Key Issues in Berlin’s Election?

    Berlin Wiki: What Are the Key Issues in Berlin’s Election?

    Why Is Rent Policy a Central Issue in Berlin’s Election Campaign? Around 85 percent of Berliners live in rented accommodation. At the same time, the housing market in the capital is tight: rents are rising, new housing construction remains sluggish, and legal loopholes frequently allow furnished apartments to be offered at inflated prices. This is…

  • A Mayor Tandem for Berlin

    A Mayor Tandem for Berlin

    What if Berlin had two Regierende Bürgermeister:innen? One representing the city’s elected voice — and another representing the voice of Berlin’s international residents who live, work and contribute here but do not have German citizenship and therefore cannot vote in Berlin elections. Because in a democratic society, it can’t be right that 25% of the…

  • Berlin Wiki: Equal Access to Democracy

    Berlin Wiki: Equal Access to Democracy

    What Impact Does Berlin’s Electoral Reform Have? In September 2023, Berlin’s House of Representatives (AGH) adopted an amendment to the state constitution lowering the voting age from 18 to 16. The aim of the constitutional amendment is to strengthen the democratic participation of young people. The new rule will apply for the first time in…

  • No German Passport? You May Still Have a Vote in Berlin 

    No German Passport? You May Still Have a Vote in Berlin 

    If you are an EU citizen living in Berlin but do not have German citizenship, you cannot vote in the election for Berlin’s House of Representatives (Abgeordnetenhaus). But you can vote for your local District Assembly (Bezirksverordnetenversammlung, or BVV) if you meet the eligibility requirements. Around 240,000 non-German EU citizens are eligible to take part…

  • The Signature That Didn’t Count – Finding My Voice in Berlin

    The Signature That Didn’t Count – Finding My Voice in Berlin

    When I moved to Berlin in the spring of 2022, I was approached one sunny afternoon by people carrying clipboards under their arms. Would I like to sign a petition? I was pleasantly surprised by this request – such a sense of community in Berlin, what a place to have come to live. With a…

  • StimmlosTrend: A New Survey Wants to Hear Berlin’s Missing Voices

    StimmlosTrend: A New Survey Wants to Hear Berlin’s Missing Voices

    Can’t vote in Berlin? There are a million people like you. We’re giving them a voice. That’s the message of WahlheYmat’s new StimmlosTrend campaign, which launches today. Modern democracy is built on elections. In Berlin, the House of Representatives is elected every five years by eligible German citizens (EU citizens can only vote in district…

  • “Berlin taught me to dislike the word integration” 

    “Berlin taught me to dislike the word integration” 

    WHP: You worked in humanitarian aid around the world for many years. What ultimately motivated you to found Just-Go-For-It? Marilena Chatziantoniou: I started working in the field of humanitarian aid in 1998. My first assignment was in Albania, where I worked for a small German NGO, just months before the Kosovo crisis. I remember falling…

  • What is Germany’s greatest asset?

    What is Germany’s greatest asset?

    “Football is a simple game. Twenty-two men chase a ball for 90 minutes and, in the end, the Germans always win,” said Gary Lineker after England lost the 1990 World Cup semi-final on penalties against Germany. Times are changing. Germany no longer always wins at major football tournaments. And England now has a German coach.…

  • Migrants With Degrees Are Not What Germany Is Looking For

    Migrants With Degrees Are Not What Germany Is Looking For

    Education is a right, not a privilege. This idea has been a founding principle of modern democracies. In practice, however, access to education is far from guaranteed for everyone. As of this year, Germany has significantly restricted access to state-funded intermediate and advanced German courses for migrants participating voluntarily. Many rejected asylum seekers, people with…

  • Berlin Wiki: Ways to Influence Politics in Berlin

    Berlin Wiki: Ways to Influence Politics in Berlin

    What is a Volksentscheid? A Volksentscheid, or referendum, allows Berliners to vote directly on proposed legislation and political issues outside regular elections, or to trigger an early election. Anyone who is eligible to vote in elections to the Berlin House of Representatives (Abgeordnetenhaus) is also eligible to take part in a Volksentscheid. A Volksentscheid can…

  • Berlin Wiki: How Berlin’s Government Is Formed

    Berlin Wiki: How Berlin’s Government Is Formed

    How Is the Government Formed? Berlin’s state government is the Senate. It consists of the Governing Mayor and ten senators. Every five years, a new Senate is formed. During coalition negotiations, the parliamentary groups agree on common political goals, the distribution of government portfolios and the budget. Afterwards, the members of the Berlin House of…

  • Berlin Wiki: Democracy and the Principles of Free Elections

    Berlin Wiki: Democracy and the Principles of Free Elections

    What Does Democracy Mean? A great deal could be written about what democracy is. Put simply, in a democracy, all state authority is derived from the people. This means that the citizens of a country determine its political direction. Germany is a parliamentary and representative democracy: citizens elect representatives who make decisions on their behalf.…

  • Berlin Wiki: Who Influences Political Decisions? 

    Berlin Wiki: Who Influences Political Decisions? 

    What Is Lobbying? Lobbying is the organised effort by interest groups to influence political decisions. The term is derived from the word “lobby,” referring to the entrance halls of parliaments where representatives of various interests traditionally met with members of parliament to discuss and promote their concerns. Lobbying takes place in almost every area of…

  • Berlin Wiki: Finding Reliable Information Before You Vote

    Berlin Wiki: Finding Reliable Information Before You Vote

    What Is the Wahl-O-Mat? The Wahl-O-Mat has been provided by the Federal Agency for Civic Education (Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung, bpb) since 2002. It is an online voting advice tool that allows users to compare their own political positions with those of political parties in Germany. Anyone using the Wahl-O-Mat can respond to a series…

  • Berlin Wiki: Understanding Political Parties

    Berlin Wiki: Understanding Political Parties

    What Is an Election Manifesto? Before an election, political parties present their election manifestos. This applies in federal, state, and local elections. In the manifestos, parties set out in writing the goals they intend to pursue. These goals reflect the issues that are important to the party during the upcoming legislative term—that is, the electoral…

Address

Am Hamburger Bahnhof 3
10557 Berlin
Germany

hey@wahlheymat.de

Social Networks