Stay: The New Migration Challenge Germany Can’t Ignore

Ivan Gabor,

Willkommen
Germany urgently needs international talent — yet one in four newcomers is considering leaving again. In his latest reflection, Ivan Gabor argues that the real challenge isn’t only attracting workers, but building a society where they want to stay. He calls for a bold narrative shift: a Germany that integrates itself into an inclusive, collaborative, future-ready reality.

If nothing changes demographically, Germany will have 16 million fewer workers by 2060 than today. According to most projections, the country needs around 400,000 new workers every year from abroad.

We often hear this fact in the news, but what we hear much less about is how many international people leave Germany again—and this seems to be becoming a growing problem. A new study shows that one in four people who come from abroad considers leaving. The reasons vary — family, work, returning home — but every second person in this group thinks about leaving because of the political climate. And it’s not rocket science to guess why: people with a migration background who have no intention of leaving are particularly worried by words like “Remigration” or “Passdeutsch.”

In Germany, over 10 million people were born outside the country. The share of the population varies widely depending on the region. In Berlin or Bremen, it is around 30% (including those who obtained citizenship); in Saxony, about 8%. I spoke with someone from Saxony-Anhalt who told me: “You in Berlin can’t even imagine how strong the hostility towards migrants (‘Migrationsfeindlichkeit’) is in my region.”

So what can be done?

One response from the federal government was the creation of a new agency called Work and Stay, designed to bring people in and help them remain in the country.

A strong example from civil society is Workstadt in Wuppertal. They run a “stay” programme financed by companies. The average recruitment cost of one skilled worker is €27,000, which means a company that needs 100 workers a year spends close to €3 million just to bring people here. So if — statistically — one in four leaves again, this creates a massive loss. That is why companies in Wuppertal contribute a fee to fund Workstadt. Their work has not only social value but a very clear economic one.

In discussions with people across various levels, one thing becomes clear: we need a narrative shift in the field of migration. A new mindset about how we see society and the role of international people within it. To put it very clearly: not only immigrants need “integration” — the whole society needs to integrate, to adapt to a new, inclusive, collaborative reality. A society that runs on technology and AI. The question is how humans can get the most out of technology while remaining human – and how Germany can transform into an international society where everyone proudly keeps their cultural roots.

Inclusivity, digitalisation, humanity, local democracy, solidarity — these are the driving forces behind the most innovative societies in the world, from Taiwan to Finland. The key in such a transformation lies in decentralised networks and in building an innovative system that can feed and strengthen those networks.

We would love to hear your thoughts on this topic.
Write to us at heypost@wahlheymat.de

Author:

More From WahlheYmatPost

  • No True German — What It Means to Be German in 2026

    No True German — What It Means to Be German in 2026

    Is there really one German identity that defines all Germans? One German identity to rule them all? We’re going to get into this question, but bear with me for a few paragraphs. I want to take a moment up front to provide a little context, tell you where I’m coming from.  We’re going to dip…

  • Berlin Wiki: From Postal Voting to the Ballot Box 

    Berlin Wiki: From Postal Voting to the Ballot Box 

    How Does Postal Voting Work? In Germany, voters can choose to vote by post instead of going to a polling station on election day. Information on how to apply for postal voting can be found in the voter notification that eligible voters receive in the weeks before the election. Depending on the municipality, voter notifications…

  • From Peru to Berlin: Building Bridges Between Different Ways of Knowing 

    From Peru to Berlin: Building Bridges Between Different Ways of Knowing 

    Are degrees really the only measure of knowledge? Should humans focus on altering nature or adapting to it? Do international studies actually include perspectives from all around the world? Academic credentials, adapting nature to suit modern lifestyles and Eurocentric education are standards that are rarely questioned.  Marita Orbegoso Alvarez, Peruvian educator, community organizer and activist,…

  • Finding Trauma Instead of Belonging: A Review of I Keep My Shadow Light 

    Finding Trauma Instead of Belonging: A Review of I Keep My Shadow Light 

    TL;DR “I Keep My Shadow Light” is the self-published debut novel by Fionnuala Kavanagh. This challenging work follows a cast of four characters from different backgrounds as they try to find a home in Berlin. Very dark in places, the book gives us a chance to read something that would probably never come out of…

  • Migrants With Degrees Are Not What Germany Is Looking For

    Migrants With Degrees Are Not What Germany Is Looking For

    Education is a right, not a privilege. This idea has been a founding principle of modern democracies. In practice, however, access to education is far from guaranteed for everyone. As of this year, Germany has significantly restricted access to state-funded intermediate and advanced German courses for migrants participating voluntarily. Many rejected asylum seekers, people with…

  • Berlin Wiki: The Overlooked Election — BVV and Local Democratic Participation

    Berlin Wiki: The Overlooked Election — BVV and Local Democratic Participation

    How Does the BVV Election Work? On September 20, Berlin goes to the polls. On that day, the election to the House of Representatives (Abgeordnetenhaus) will take place, along with the elections to the District Council Assemblies (Bezirksverordnetenversammlungen, BVV). Berlin is divided into twelve districts, each of which elects its own District Council Assembly. This…

  • Berlin Wiki: Who Makes Decisions in the Districts?

    Berlin Wiki: Who Makes Decisions in the Districts?

    What Does a District Office Do? A Berlin district office (Bezirksamt) manages the administration of one of Berlin’s twelve districts and serves as the district’s political leadership. It consists of the district mayor and five district councillors (Bezirksstadträte), who are elected by the district assembly (Bezirksverordnetenversammlung, BVV). The district office implements adopted laws and policies.…

  • Berlin Wiki: How Berlin’s Government Works 

    Berlin Wiki: How Berlin’s Government Works 

    What Makes Berlin’s Governing Mayor Special? Whoever holds the office of Governing Mayor is both the head of government and the ceremonial head of the city of Berlin. The House of Representatives (Abgeordnetenhaus) votes on who will hold the position. There has even been a case in which someone won the election without being their…

  • Berlin Wiki: How Do the First and Second Vote Work? 

    Berlin Wiki: How Do the First and Second Vote Work? 

    What Does the First Vote Decide? The article looks at how voters elect candidates and parties in Bundestag elections and elections to the Berlin House of Representatives, and how seats in parliament are distributed through proportional representation. In Bundestag elections or elections to the House of Representatives, voters cast both a first vote and a…

  • Tempelhofer Feld: Berlin’s Most Emotional Urban Conflict Is Back 

    Tempelhofer Feld: Berlin’s Most Emotional Urban Conflict Is Back 

    We are approaching an election in September. Hopefully, you’re reading along in the Berlin Wiki to bone up on how stuff works in German elections, the lexicon, and the issues. Well, one of the issues we’re going to see debated concerns the Tempelhofer Feld. So let’s talk about that for a bit.  The other night,…

  • Berlin Wiki: Parties, Direct Mandates and the Five-Percent Threshold 

    Berlin Wiki: Parties, Direct Mandates and the Five-Percent Threshold 

    What Is a Political Party? A political party is an association of citizens regulated by the German Federal Party Law. Political parties aim to influence political decision-making at federal or state level over a longer period of time and may represent voters in state parliaments or in the Bundestag. First of all, a party needs…

  • Good Intentions Are Not Democratic Enough

    Good Intentions Are Not Democratic Enough

    “What you do for me, but without me, you do against me” — the exact origin of this quote is unclear. Nevertheless, it captures something that frequently happens in Germany when it comes to the political participation of historically excluded groups. Policies are supposedly made for migrants, yet not with them. Gender equality is debated…

  • What Happened When I Tried to Organize My Neighbors 

    What Happened When I Tried to Organize My Neighbors 

    There’s a lot of talk today about building community. At our March WahlheYmat Talk, the crowd brought up the subject, specifically that we should be creating more of it. Ideas flew around the room. We are living in an era of schism, where the people pulling the levers of power are trying to create an…

  • Berlin Wiki: Who Is Allowed to Vote – and Why Not Everyone Can

    Berlin Wiki: Who Is Allowed to Vote – and Why Not Everyone Can

    Who is allowed to vote, and who is not? In a democratic state like Germany, the right to vote is of central importance. It allows citizens to take part in political decision-making and help determine the composition of the government. In Germany, voters must meet certain requirements in order to vote. They must hold German…

  • Berlin Wiki: Party Profiles II – The Greens, The Left, the AfD and the BSW party

    Berlin Wiki: Party Profiles II – The Greens, The Left, the AfD and the BSW party

    What is the Green Party? Bündnis 90/Die Grünen is an important political force in the Berlin House of Representatives. Although the party has not been part of the government since the 2023 election, it operates from the opposition within parliament. Its guiding principle is ecological, economic, and social sustainability. It focuses on stronger climate protection,…

Address

Am Hamburger Bahnhof 3
10557 Berlin
Germany

hey@wahlheymat.de

Social Networks